What are Trade Remedies in Vietnam?

  When participating in the process of international economic integration, every country voluntarily cut off the trade barriers for goods to easily circulate among each other. However, in the legal framework of World Trade Organization (WTO), the countries are allowed to impose trade remedies if satisfying certain conditions. Vietnam has officially become a member of WTO since July 11 2007 and the imposing of these trade remedies are regulated in Law on foreign trade management 2018.

According to Law on foreign trade management 2018, trade remedies includes anti-dumping measure, countervailing measure and safeguard measure. Specifically, (i) Anti-dumping measure imposed on imports into Vietnam is a measure imposed on products that are dumped when being imported to Vietnam, which causes material injury or threaten to cause material injury to domestic industry or retard the establishment of the domestic industry; (ii) Countervailing measure imposed on imports into Vietnam is a measure imposed on products that are subsidized when being imported to Vietnam, which causes the material injury or threat of material injury to the domestic industry or retards the establishment of the domestic industry; (iii) Safeguard measure imposed on foreign products imported into Vietnam is measure imposed on increased imports of particular products to Vietnam, which causes the serious injury or threat of serious injury to the domestic industry.

The domestic industry mentioned above refers to the producers as a whole of the like products within the territory of Vietnam or those whose collective output of the like products constitutes a major proportion of domestic production of those products. Besides, the injury to domestic industry shall be determined on each level: (i) Material injury to domestic industry; (ii) threat of material injury to domestic industry; (iii) material retardation of establishment of a domestic industry; (iv)serious injury to domestic industry; (v) threat of serious injury to domestic industry.

Due to the imposing of these remedies directly affecting to foreign producer/exporter as well as domestic industry, thus, it is required to comply to six following rules when imposing these remedies:

Firstly, impose measures within the reasonable scope and level for a certain period of time to protect domestic industry, prevent or limit the injury to it;

Secondly, only impose measures after the investigation is carried out transparently and fairly in accordance with regulations of law and based on determinations of the investigation;

Thirdly, decisions on the investigation and the imposition of trade remedies shall be published;

Fourthly, if the duty rate of an official trade remedy is higher than those of a provisional trade remedy, the difference of duty will not be collected;

Fifthly, if the duty rate of an official trade remedy is lower than those of the provisional trade remedy, the difference of duty will be returned;

Sixthly, if the Minister of Industry and Trade does not impose an official trade remedy, the duty of provisional trade remedy that has been collected or the amount for ensuring the payment of temporary trade remedy duties shall be returned.

If Client needs any more information or request for legal advice regarding trade remedies measures including: anti-dumping, countervailing duty and safeguard measures or international trade dispute matters, Our international trade and tax lawyers, and antitrust lawyers at ANT Lawyers, a law firm in Vietnam have always followed the development of situation and update the clients on relevant matters.

Read More

What Need to Know About Dispute between Foreign Investor and Host State?

 

 In the globalization and international integration in general as well as economic integration in particular, foreign investment including foreign direct investment (FDI) and indirect foreign investment in countries are increasing significant.  This trend also comes along with the growth of international investment dispute between foreign investor and host state (or related state agencies). This dispute is often complex with huge amount of compensation demanded by the investor.

Subjects of this dispute include foreign investor (plaintiff) and host state or related state agencies (defendant). In particular, Vietnam laws stipulate that foreign investor means an individual holding a foreign nationality or an organization established under foreign laws an making business investment in Vietnam. The second subject is state, a “special” subject because this subject is the beneficiary of “jurisdictional immunity”. Specifically, jurisdictional immunity is a right of a state which do not be judged by any international or national jurisdiction without the consent of such state.

This dispute shall relate to the investment of foreign investor in host state according to regulation of (i) investment law of host state; (ii) treaty of promotion and protection of investment (bilateral investment treaty - BIT) or investment chapter in bilateral/regional trade agreements; or (iii) contract relating to investment of foreign investor and competent state agencies.

To promote foreign investment and to protect investors, countries around the world as well as Vietnam have signed and will sign bilateral agreements on promotion and protection of investment (BIT), agreement between countries on promotion and protection of investment (international investment agreement – IIA), free trade agreement (FTA) having investment chapter. Accordingly, investor holding the nationality of a signatory to investment agreement (chapter) is entitled to have full protection and security, fair and equitable treatment, non-discrimination, no expropriation... of investment according to regulation of such investment agreement (chapter) in host state. Besides, to ensure that dispute between foreign investor and host state will be fairly and properly settled and to prevent the case of refering to jurisdictional immunity to avoid being sued, there are provisions on dispute settlement mechanisms between foreign investor and host state in most of these agreements.

Through investment agreement (chapter), the host state abandons its right of jurisdictional immunity to be sued and judged at competent jurisdiction. If the host state violates and harms the foreign investor, such country shall compensate according to judgement of that jurisdiction. Jurisdictions being competent to resolve disputes between foreign investor and host state may be arbitration, court of the host state; international arbitration; or other jurisdictions by agreement between the parties.

Behaviours which state violates commitment on investment protection may be very broad, including: (i) expropriation such as: requisition or nationalization without compensation; “indirect” requisition or “according to regulation” without reasonable compensation; (ii) no fair and equitable treatment; (iii) no full protection and security; (iv) there is discrimination such as violation of most favoured nation and national treatment; (v) and/or other violations such as: legal obligation/commitment, right of withdrawing investment and interest, compensation due to war or riot.

Dispute resolution process between foreign investor and host state usually takes place with three stages, including (i) conflict management stage means carrying out resolving complaints and consultation, mediation; (ii) dispute resolution stage; and (iii) implementation stage. In above process, consulting with international dispute lawyers to for resolution of international investment disputes is a very important and necessary.

Read More

How Foreigners Could Buy Real Estate in Vietnam?

  Regulations on foreigners owning real estate in Vietnam are regulated in Civil Code 2015, Law on Land 2013, Law on Housing 2014, Decree no. 99/2015/ND- CP on guidelines the Law on Housing and related documents.

For land, foreign individuals are not eligible to use land assigned or leased by the State, recognized land use rights, received transfer of land use rights. However, a foreign-invested enterprise could be allocated or leased land by the State, recognized land use rights, or received a land use right transfer. Foreign-invested enterprises that are assigned land by the State with the collection of land use levies to execute investment projects on the construction of houses for sale or for sale in combination with lease.

For housing, foreign entities eligible for the homeownership in Vietnam include: foreign entities who invest in project-based housing construction in Vietnam as prescribed in this Law and corresponding regulations of law; foreign-invested enterprises, branches, representative offices of foreign enterprises, foreign-invested funds and branches of foreign banks operating in Vietnam (hereinafter referred to as foreign organization); foreign individuals who are allowed to enter Vietnam.

The foreign entities are eligible for the homeownership in Vietnam if they invest in project-based housing construction in Vietnam as prescribed in this Law and corresponding regulations of law; or buy, rent and purchase, receive, or inherit commercial housing including apartments and separate houses in the project for housing construction, except for areas under management relating to national defense and security as prescribed in regulations of the Government.

Foreign organizations and individuals must have documents proving being the eligible subjects and meeting conditions to own houses in Vietnam. A foreign individual must have an unexpired passport bearing the entry seal of the Vietnam’s immigration authority and not given diplomatic immunity and privileges according to Ordinance on diplomatic immunity and privileges of diplomatic missions, consular offices, and representative authorities of international organizations in Vietnam. Foreign organizations must be subjects of owning houses in Vietnam which have investment registration certificate or a permission issued by a Vietnam’s competent authority for operation in Vietnam which is still unexpired at the time of housing transaction (hereinafter referred to as investment registration certificate).

A foreign entity shall not be granted a Certificate of the house and may only sell or offer it to another entity eligible to own housing in Vietnam in the case being: a foreign organization or individual receives a house as an inheritance or a gift which is located in an area in which foreign entities must not own houses, or the quantity of which exceeds the permissible limits; a foreign organization that does not operate in Vietnam, or a foreign individual who is not permitted to enter Vietnam, receives a house in Vietnam as a gift or an inheritance.

For specific situations, to avoid future dispute in house ownership arisen from the purchase, lease of property, house, land from the state, developer or other seller, or lessor it is important that the client check with property lawyers for eligibility, conditions and other relevant matters.

If you are interested in buying and selling real estate in Vietnam, please contact a law firm in Vietnam for the fastest advice.

Read More

Vietnam to Investigate Anti-Dumping Case of Sorbitol Chemical Products from China, India and Indonesia

  On August 18^th, 2020, Trade Remedies Authority of Vietnam (TRAV) acknowledged the Dossier on request of investigation to impose the anti-dumping measures to Sorbitol chemical products originated from China, India and Indonesia from the companies representing the domestic industry (Requester).  If there is anti-dumping actions, the anti-dumping investigation will be initiated and related parties would cooperate with TRAV to provide data as required.

On the basis of assessing the Dossier, on September 30^th, 2020, TRAV had confirmed the sufficiency of the dossiers according the the laws on trade remedy.

Within 45 days from the date of receiving sufficient and lawful dossier, TRAV will assess dossier to submit Minister of Ministry of Industry and Trade for consideration whether to process the investigation.

The assessment’s contents includes:

-Identify the legal representative status of the domestic industry of organizations and individuals who submit dossier in accordance with the Law on Foreign Trade Management;

-Define evidence on the dumping of imported goods that cause or threaten to cause significant losses to a domestic manufacturing industry or substantially prevent the formation of a domestic manufacturing industry.

In order to serve the assessment process, as well as to ensure the legitimate rights and interests of the enterprise, TRAV recommends that the domestic enterprises manufacturing trading in the same goods mentioned above provide the following information.

• Enterprise’s information;
• Capacity/design and production of Sorbitol chemical products in 2017, 2018, 2019 and 2020;
• Enterprise’s opinion on the case (to agree, oppose, have no opinion);
• Any document/evidence which companies consider to be related to the case

The due date to provide the above information is before 5p.m October 16^th, 2020.

Our competition, anti-dumping, and countervailing duty lawyers of international trade and tax practice at ANT Lawyers, a law firm in Vietnam always follow up trade remedy development to update clients on regular basis.

Read More

How to Obtain Construction Practicing Licenses in Vietnam?

  The Construction Practicing License (practicing license) shall be issued to any Vietnamese citizens, overseas Vietnamese or foreigners who legally carry out construction activities in Vietnam in order to hold certain positions or operate their own construction business as prescribed in the amended Law on Construction 2020.

Holders of titles and individuals practicing construction activities who are required to possess practicing licenses as prescribed in Law on Construction include construction investment project managers, construction planning design managers, construction survey managers, construction design or design verification managers, construction supervision consultants, and managers in charge of formulating, verifying and managing construction investment costs. Any foreigner who obtained a practicing certificate issued by a foreign authority or organization and has practiced construction in Vietnam for less than 06 months shall be permitted to practise construction activities. If he or she has practised construction in Vietnam for at least 06 months, he or she is required to change the construction practicing license.

A foreigner shall be issued with the practicing license if he or she: has full legal capacity as prescribed by law and obtains a residence permit or work permit in Vietnam; has qualifications and experience relevant to requirements of the practicing certificate; passes the test in the field that is covered by the practice license applied for.

Practicing licenses shall be classified into Rank-I, Rank-II and Rank-III. In particular, a Rank-I practicing license is granted to the individual who gains a bachelor's degree in appropriate major and at least 07 years’ experience relevant to requirements of that practicing license; a Rank-II practicing license is granted to the individual who gains a bachelor's degree in appropriate major and at least 04 years’ experience relevant to requirements of that practicing license; a Rank-III practicing license is granted to the individual who has appropriate qualifications and at least 02 years’ experience relevant to requirements of that practicing license with respect to the holder of the undergraduate degree and at least 03 years’ experience with respect to the holder of the associate degree or intermediate diploma.

The competence authority in Vietnam to grant practice licenses: the construction-specialized agencies directly under the Ministry of Construction shall grant Rank-I practicing licenses; The Department of Construction issues Rank-II, Rank-III practicing license and recognized socio-professional organizations grant Rank-II, Rank-III practicing license to individuals who are their members and members.

An application for issuance of the construction practicing license for the first time includes: An application form enclosed with the applicant’s 02 color 4 x 6 cm and white background pictures which are taken within the last 06 months; Qualification(s) granted by a legal training institution in accordance with the type or rank of the certificate applied for; Decisions on task assignment (responsibility assignment) issued by an organization to an individual or written confirmation of completed typical tasks provided by the legal representative of the investor, in case the individual runs his/her own construction business, a contract and record on commissioning of listed typical tasks are required; Legal residence-related documents or work permit issued by a Vietnam competent authority, applicable to foreigners. The above documents must be notarized, legalized, authenticated then translated with certified true copies into Vietnamese or included in a file that contains color photos of originals or copies presented together with the originals for comparison. Besides, satisfactory test result in case the test is done before the date of submission of the application for the practicing license.

For application of the practicing license, the applicant shall submit an application form for issuance of the practicing license, electronically or by post or in person, to the issuing authority. From the date on which the satisfactory application is received, the issuing authority shall issue the construction practicing license within 20 days in the case of issuance of the license for the first time. In the case the application is unsatisfactory, the issuing authority shall notify the applicant in writing once within 05 days from the date on which the application is received.

The practicing license of a foreign individual, its effective period shall be determined according to the period specified in the work permit or temporary resident card issued by a competent authority but not exceed 05 years.

The above are provisions on the process of granting construction practicing licenses for foreign individuals working in Vietnam under the amended Law on Construction 2020. The amended Law on Construction 2020 takes effect from January 1, 2021.

ANT Lawyers, a law firms in Vietnam with offices in Hanoi, Da Nang, Ho Chi Minh city could assist clients with application process.

Read More

What Are Tax Obligations of a Representative Office in Vietnam?

  Vietnam-based representative office of a foreign trader means a dependent unit of the foreign trader, which is established under the provisions of Vietnamese law to conduct market survey and a number of commercial promotion activities permitted by Vietnamese law.

Representative office of foreign trader in Vietnam has the rights and obligations in accordance with the law of Vietnam. Foreign trader is responsible before the law of Vietnam for all operations of its representative office in Vietnam.

Accordingly, representative office in Vietnam is not allowed to conduct business activities, nor carry out other activities for profit-generating purposes. The representative office in Vietnam only performs the activities for the right purposes, scope and duration specified in the certificate to establish the representative office. Besides, the representative office in Vietnam has the right to rent the head office, rent and buy the facilities and materials necessary for the operation of the representative office; to recruit Vietnamese and foreign employees to work at the representative office in accordance with the provisions of Vietnamese law; to use an account in foreign currency, in Vietnam dong of foreign currency origin opened by a foreign trader at a bank licensed to operate in Vietnam and only use this account for the operation of the representative office; to have a seal bearing the name of the representative office according to the provisions of Vietnamese law. Representative office in Vietnam can sign contracts, perform transactions with partners when authorized by the enterprise.

Hence, due to the limited scope of activities, the tax liability of a foreign representative office in Vietnam is narrower than that of an enterprise.  As the representative office does not produce or trade in goods and services, it is not required to pay license fees as prescribed. Representative office of foreign trader in Vietnam is dependent unit of foreign trader, established to investigate the market and carry out some trade promotion activities permitted by Vietnamese law, does not carry out production and business activities, so it is not required to pay license fees.

The fact that the representative office has the right to recruit Vietnamese or foreign employees to work at the office is the basis for arising personal income tax obligation. At the same time, representative office of foreign organization is subject to personal income tax registration. For employees working at foreign representative office in Vietnam, the taxable incomes are based on salaries and wages. Declaring, withholding, paying taxes and settling personal income tax of employees working at foreign representative office is the responsibility of such representative office.

ANT Lawyers, a law firm in Vietnam with offices in Hanoi, Da Nang and Ho Chi Minh City could help client to set up representative office in Vietnam and advise on the compliance on regular basis.

Read More

What Are Fundamental Contract Breaches in Law on Commerce 2005 and CISG 1980?

 

 Fundamental breach is a type of contract breach, in which the Law on Commerce 2005 defines that a breach of contract committed by one of the parties is fundamental if it causes damage to the other party to the extent that the other party fails to achieve purpose of contract conclusion. The significant factor that makes the difference between the fundamental and minor breach of contract is the materiality.

Fundamental breach is an important foundation for the imposition of trade remedies such as temporary suspension of performance, suspension of performance or contract cancellation when the contract has no specific agreement. Nonetheless, Law on Commerce 2005 does not provide further guidance on fundamental breach. Court or arbitrator has a right to determine whether a breach is fundamental on a case-by-case basis.

As set forth in CISG 1980, a breach of contract committed by one of the parties is fundamental if it results in such detriment to the other party as substantially to deprive him of what he is entitled to expect under the contract, unless the party in breach did not foresee and a reasonable person of the same kind in the same circumstances would not have foreseen such a result. CISG also does not provide specific provisions to explain fundamental breach in details. Nonetheless, it can be deemed that in order to constitute a fundamental breach, three following factors need to be met: (i) a breach is made, (ii) detriment resulted from such breach substantially deprives him of what he is entitled to expect under the contract, and (iii) the breach can be foreseen.

The difference between constitution of a fundamental breach under CIGS 19080 and Law on Commerce 2005 is that: a breach cannot be treated as under CISG 1980 in case the breaching party did not foresee and a reasonable person of the same kind in the same circumstances would not have foreseen such a result. Law on Commerce 2005 does not stipulate factor (iii) as mentioned herein but requires that (1) a breach is made and (2) damage resulted from such breach causes other party failed to achieve its purpose of contract conclusion to constitute a fundamental breach. The aggrieved party accordingly has a right to impose remedies such as temporary suspension of performance, suspension of performance or contract cancellation.

The consequence factor of fundamental breach in Law on Commerce 2005 is similar to CIGS 1980. In case the purchaser is aggrieved party, what he/she is entitled to expect under the contract is right to receive the goods, to own the goods and to sell to other parties to earn profits or manufacture products or other ways he/she can make a profit. In case the seller is aggrieved party, what he/she is entitled to expect under the contract is right to receive payments, which is profits he/she may earn. The purpose of contract conclusion as provided in Law on Commerce 2005 is same as what the purchaser and seller are entitled to expect under the contract as stipulated in CISG 1980. If you have problems with breach of contract, please contact a law firm for assistance.

Read More